From Wardship to Rights

The Guerin Case and Aboriginal Law

By Jim Reynolds
Categories: Law & Legal Studies, Indigenous Peoples & Colonial Law, Legal History, Indigenous Studies
Series: Landmark Cases in Canadian Law
Publisher: UBC Press
Hardcover : 9780774864565, 308 pages, May 2020
Paperback : 9780774864572, 308 pages, May 2020
Ebook (PDF) : 9780774864589, 308 pages, May 2020
Ebook (EPUB) : 9780774864596, 308 pages, May 2020

Table of contents

Preface

Introduction

Part 1: The Context

1 The Colonial Context

2 The Musqueam and Their Land

3 The Government as Fiduciary

Part 2: The Case

4 The Trial and Federal Court of Appeal

5 The Supreme Court of Canada

Part 3: The Consequences

6 The Impact of Guerin

Conclusion

Notes; Selected Bibliography; Index of Cases; Index

Description

This book tells the story of a First Nation’s single-minded quest for justice. In 1958, the federal government leased part of the small Musqueam Reserve in Vancouver to an exclusive golf club at below market value. When the band members discovered this in 1970, they initiated legal action. Their tenacity led to the 1984 decision in Guerin v. The Queen, whereby the Supreme Court of Canada held that the government has a fiduciary duty towards Indigenous peoples. Jim Reynolds, who served as one of the legal counsel for the Musqueam, provides an in-depth analysis of this landmark case and its impact on Canadian law, politics, and society. By recognizing that the Musqueam had enforceable legal rights, the Guerin case changed the relationship between governments and Indigenous peoples from one of wardship to one based on legal rights. It was a seismic decision.

Reviews

From Wardship to Rights is a captivating account of one of the most significant moments in Canadian legal history. Beyond its value in preserving the first-hand memories of the participants, Jim Reynolds's book offers an understandable yet uncompromised contribution to the scholarship of Canadian Aboriginal law.

- Corbin Golding