Paths to the Bench

The Judicial Appointment Process in Manitoba, 1870-1950

By Dale Brawn
Categories: History, Law & Legal Studies, Law & Society, Legal History, Canadian History
Series: Law and Society
Publisher: UBC Press
Hardcover : 9780774826754, 320 pages, September 2014
Paperback : 9780774826761, 320 pages, January 2015
Ebook (PDF) : 9780774826778, 320 pages, September 2014
Ebook (EPUB) : 9780774826785, 320 pages, September 2014

Table of contents

Introduction

1 Why Study Judges?

2 Social Origins of the Bar

3 At the Bar

4 Politics

5 Becoming Prominent

6 The Appointment Process

7 Why Lawyers Do Not Go to the Bench

8 On the Bench

Conclusion

Appendix: Brief Biographies of Judges of the Queen’s Bench, 1870-1950

Notes; Bibliography; Index

An in-depth look at how powerful men, social organizations, and eastern politicians influenced judicial appointments in early 20th-century Manitoba.

Description

Using the judiciary of Manitoba as a model, Paths to the Bench examines the political nature of Canada’s judicial appointment process and suggests that ability alone seldom determined who went to the bench. In fact, many of Manitoba’s early judges spent little time actually practising law, since professional merit was not a criterion for judicial appointments. Rather, it was relationships with influential mentors and communities that ensured appointments and ultimately propelled careers. Brawn offers an in-depth analysis of how the paths to the bench of competent and connected and less competent and connected lawyers differed. This book is one of the few studies to examine why many of the best and brightest members of the bar either did not want to go to the bench, or if they did, why they did not get there.